Comparison
Circular saw vs track saw for sheet material
Published
Note: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
In short
A track saw is a plunge circular saw that runs on its own guide rail, so it gives dead straight, splinter free cuts in worktops, doors and sheet goods with little setup. A standard circular saw with a clamped straight edge can get close, for less money, but takes longer to set up and usually chips the surface more. For frequent sheet work buy a track saw; for building work a circular saw is more versatile.
Bosch Professional
Bosch GKS 18V-57: 165 mm saw for third party rails
Check price on AmazonAffiliate linkMakita
Makita DSP600ZJ: 36 V plunge saw with 2 x 5 Ah and rail
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
- Bosch GKS 18V-57: 165 mm saw for third party rails
- Guide rail
- Bosch, Mafell, Festool and Makita rails
- In the box
- Saw, blade, parallel guide, L-BOXX 238 (no battery)
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link - Makita DSP600ZJ: 36 V plunge saw with 2 x 5 Ah and rail
- Guide rail
- Included
- In the box
- Saw, 2 x 5.0 Ah, charger, rail
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
| Product | Guide rail | In the box | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch GKS 18V-57: 165 mm saw for third party rails | Bosch, Mafell, Festool and Makita rails | Saw, blade, parallel guide, L-BOXX 238 (no battery) | Check price on AmazonAffiliate link |
| Makita DSP600ZJ: 36 V plunge saw with 2 x 5 Ah and rail | Included | Saw, 2 x 5.0 Ah, charger, rail | Check price on AmazonAffiliate link |
Details as stated in the Amazon listing or by the manufacturer. See the current price on Amazon.
Our verdict
Choose a track saw kit such as the Makita DSP600ZJ for clean, quick cuts in worktops, doors and sheets. Choose a rail compatible circular saw such as the Bosch GKS 18V-57 if you need one saw for building work that can still use a rail.
Track saws, also called plunge saws, have become the go to tool for kitchen fitters and cabinet makers, but they cost more than a standard circular saw. Is the difference worth it? This article compares how each cuts, the finish you can expect, how long setup takes and when a circular saw with a rail adaptor or straight edge is enough.
How a track saw differs
A track saw is a circular saw built around a guide rail. The base has a groove that rides on the rail, so the saw cannot wander. A rubber splinter strip on the rail edge shows the exact cut line and presses down the surface fibres, which greatly reduces chipping on veneered and laminated boards. The blade is fully enclosed and plunges down into the work when you push the saw, which also allows cut outs in the middle of a panel.
Riving knives and anti kickback features are common, and dust extraction is usually very effective because the blade is enclosed.
How a circular saw with a straight edge compares
A standard circular saw can follow a clamped straight edge, such as a factory edge of ply or an aluminium rule. You measure the offset from the blade to the edge of the base, clamp the guide that far from your line and run the saw along it. Some saws, like the Bosch GKS 18V-57, are listed as compatible with several brands of guide rail, which turns them into a partial track saw.
The difference is that the cut line is not marked by a strip, there is less support against splintering, and the saw can drift away from a loose guide. Taping the line and using a fine blade helps. See how to cut straight with a circular saw.
Two saws compared
The table compares a rail compatible circular saw with a cordless plunge saw kit that includes a rail.
| Bosch GKS 18V-57 | Makita DSP600ZJ | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Circular saw | Plunge (track) saw |
| Power | 18 V, battery not included | 36 V (2 x 18 V), 2 x 5.0 Ah included |
| Depth | 57 mm | Not stated in listing |
| Rail | Works with Bosch, Mafell, Festool, Makita rails | Rail included |
| Brake | Fast motor brake | Electric brake |
| In the box | Saw, blade, parallel guide, L-BOXX | Saw, batteries, charger, rail |
Finish, accuracy and setup time
On melamine faced chipboard, veneered ply and laminate worktops, a track saw with a sharp fine tooth blade and a fresh splinter strip gives an edge that often needs no further work. A circular saw usually leaves some chipping on the top face, though cutting with the good face down and using a fine blade helps.
Setup is the other big gain. With a track saw you lay the rail on your marks and cut. With a straight edge you measure the offset at both ends, clamp, check and then cut, which adds minutes to every cut on a big job.
| Track saw | Circular saw and straight edge | |
|---|---|---|
| Edge finish on laminate | Very clean | Some chipping likely |
| Setup per cut | Lay rail on marks | Measure offset, clamp guide |
| Plunge cut outs | Yes | Awkward and riskier |
| Framing and joists | Possible but clumsy | Ideal |
| Typical outlay | Higher | Lower |
Which to buy
Choose a track saw if you fit kitchens, build furniture, trim doors or break down lots of sheet material. Choose a circular saw if you do building work, decking, roofing and framing, where speed and depth matter more than a perfect edge. If you can only have one and do a mix, a rail compatible circular saw is a sensible middle way.
Compare models in our plunge and track saw guide and cordless circular saw guide.
Note:Support the sheet fully on both sides of the cut so the kerf does not close and pinch the blade, set the depth just below the material, and keep the cord or battery clear. Wear eye, ear and dust protection and follow the manual and HSE guidance.
Dust and indoor use
Cutting MDF and chipboard indoors produces fine dust. Track saws usually connect to an extractor and capture most of it, which makes them popular for work in occupied homes. Circular saws throw dust out of the side port unless you connect a vacuum.
Whichever saw you use, connect extraction where possible and wear a suitable dust mask.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use any rail with any track saw? No. Rails are brand specific, though several brands share a similar profile. Check the saw's listing for rail compatibility, as with the HiKOKI C3606DPA which lists several brands.
Is a track saw as good as a table saw? For breaking down full sheets it is often better, because you move the saw rather than the sheet. For repeated narrow rips, a table saw is faster.
Can a track saw cut 45 degree bevels? Most can, with the blade tilting on the rail. Check the bevel range in the listing.
Do I need a long rail? A 1.4 m rail covers doors and many worktop cuts. For full 2.4 m sheets you need two joined rails or one long one.
What you need
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
Makita DSP600ZJ: 36 V plunge saw with 2 x 5 Ah and rail
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
Makita DHS660RTJ: brushless saw kit, 2 x 5 Ah
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
Evolution R255TBL+: 255 mm, 85 mm deep, rack and pinion fence